Up close shot of heart sourdough loaf

How to Make a Valentine’s Day Heart Sourdough Loaf (Artistic Scoring Tutorial)

This Valentine’s Day heart sourdough loaf is a great place to start if you’ve ever wanted to try decorative bread art without the complicated steps! Instead of intricate scoring or string tying, this loaf relies on stencils and naturally colored flours to create soft pink and red hearts with a dimensional, pop-up finish.

I made the stencils myself using cardstock and my Cricut Joy– I highly recommend it. This makes the entire process approachable even if you’re new to artistic scoring. Alternatively, you could print out hearts on cardstock and cut them out- it will just take longer.

If you’re looking for another gorgeous design that feels seasonal and eye catching take a peek at my Pink Lace Pumpkin Sourdough. If you make either design, I’d love to see them- tag me @the.sourdough.mama on instagram so I can admire your beautiful bakes!

Up close shot of Valentine's Day Heart Sourdough Loaf

Watch the Process

In addition to the steps outlined below, I highly recommend watching the reel I created for this loaf HERE for visual reference. It will give a bit of extra guidance to ensure you are a success with your Valentine’s Day Heart Sourdough Loaf.

Note: This post contains some ads and affiliate links. If you purchase through a link, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my work and helping me continue sharing sourdough tutorials!

What you’ll need

  • Basic sourdough boule- 72% hydration works beautifully.
    Need a recipe? Use my Go-To Sourdough Bread Recipe here or the recipe card below.
  • Pastry Brush– for wiping off the dough and the stencil between applications
  • Spray or mister bottle– for wetting the dough
  • Pink flour– for the pink hearts. This flour needs to be made- learn how I make my naturally colored flours HERE (the recipe for pink is included!)
  • Red Yeast Rice Powder– for the red hearts and that all natural deep red hue
  • Flour Duster (optional tool that helps sprinkle on the flour- I love mine!)
  • Cricut Joy and two 5 x 7 cardstock sheets or heart stencils
  • Sharp lame or razor blade
  • Dutch Oven- I love my Challenger Breadpan or this beauty from Le Creuset!
  • Optional: you can find a variety of other ideas for colors HERE in my Naturally Colored Flours Guide
  • Optional tools — shop more of my favorites HERE

Cricut Stencil Templates

Cricut Joy and stencils
Cricut Joy
Small heart template cricut
Small Heart Template
Large heart template cricut
Large Heart Template

This design becomes SO EASY when you use a Cricut Joy. I held off on purchasing for years but now that I own one- I am so glad. For this design you will need to make two simple heart stencils:

  • Small Heart Stencil: Used for applying the colored flour design before baking.
  • Large Heart Stencil: Used after the initial bake to guide the perimeter cut and create a raised, three-dimensional heart.

I created both stencils using cardstock, which works well for short contact with wet dough. The photos above include the dimensions of my templates so you can recreate them easily at home. I selected one of the free heart shapes within the cricut app, sized it accordingly, and centered it on the paper so I would have a nice border to shield the flour while I applied the flour.

Dough Schedule (Example)

(Full printable PDF available in my Resources Library)

Night Before

10:00 PM — Prepare your levain (starter you will use to bake with):
10g starter + 50g flour + 50g water
(Adjust based on your kitchen temperature. This works well around 75°F.)

need a starter?

Dehydrated Sourdough Starter

Day 1

8:00 AM — Mix + fermentolyse
9:00 AM — Begin stretch & folds
Bulk ferment 7–8 hours with 3–4 folds (varies by climate and dough temp)
4:00 PM — Shape + cold proof overnight

Day 2

10:00 AM — Freeze dough 30–45 minutes (for crisp scoring)
Preheat oven to 500°F with Dutch oven inside
11:00 AM — Bake at 430°F
20 minutes covered + 20–25 minutes uncovered

Step-by-Step Valentine’s Day Heart Sourdough Design

1. Prep the Dough

brushing flour off of the sourdough boule
  • Freeze dough 30–45 minutes while your dutch oven pre-heats in the oven at 500°F
  • Place your colored powders and stencils at your scoring station
  • Bring the chilled dough to your scoring station and flip over onto parchment or a BreadMat and remove the banneton
  • Brush off excess flour
  • Spritz the entire surface with water so it is fully coated in a thin layer of water. The dough should be glistening but not dripping

2. Apply the Heart Design

applying the colored powder to the stencil
wiping off excess flour from the heart stencil
lifting the heart stencil off the dough
  • Place the small heart stencil on top of the damp dough and press it in slightly for a tight seal.
  • Using a flour duster, sprinkle the pink flour or red powder inside the heart.
  • Once sprinkled, gently smooth the powder with your fingers.
  • Carefully lift the stencil up by slowly rocking it side to side until it lifts to reveal the heart design.
  • Continue adding hearts to your dough, alternating colors, and leaving a bit of space between each. If needed, you can apply more water to the surface of the dough as it dries out using a small wet brush or damp fingers.

Pro Tip: Move swiftly to help your powders adhere easily and keep the dough from drying out too much- as the surface dries you can re-apply water but it’s best to move as quickly as you can rather than constantly re-wetting the dough.

3. The 5-Minute Expansion Score (Covered Bake)

cutting out the 3D heart stencil design
  • Lower your oven heat to 430°F and bake the dough covered for 5 minutes.
  • Note:
    • If your dough tends to split early or set quickly, reduce to 3–4 minutes.
    • If it’s still too soft and jiggly, extend to 6–7 minutes.
    • You want the dough to be firm enough to lift portions but not baked to the point where it is no longer flexible. This may take some trial and error!
  • Remove the Dutch oven from the oven and take out the dough (if the dutch oven sides will be in the way when you go to score the dough).
  • Place the larger heart stencil centered over the dough.
  • Using a sharp lame, carefully cut around the perimeter of the larger heart.
    • Aim for a clean, confident cut.
    • This outer cut is what allows the heart shape to lift and pop up during the rest of the bake.
    • Note: if your dough tends to burst with minimal scoring like this, mine did, try making a large circular cut all along the bottom outside edge of your dough- this can help alleviate the splitting. I wish I had remembered to do this with mine!
  • Return the dough to the Dutch oven and bake covered for 15 more minutes.

4. Finish Baking (Uncovered Bake)

Lifting the edges of the cut out heart shape
Par-baked heart sourdough
  • Uncover and continue baking for another 20-ish minutes, or until golden
  • You may want to loosely cover the popped up heart with foil to prevent it from over-browning
  • Transfer your finished loaf to a cooling rack and let it cool for at least 30 minutes.

Final Thoughts

  • This Valentine’s Day heart loaf is a perfect example of how simple techniques can create impactful bread art. Whether you’re baking for someone special or just want to try something festive and fun, this design is approachable, customizable, and incredibly satisfying to pull from the oven! Happy Valentine’s Day!
  • If you make this design, I’d love to see it- tag me @the.sourdough.mama so I can admire your beautiful bake.
Baked Valentine's Day Heart Sourdough Loaf

Want More Sourdough Art?

If you loved this design, you’ll adore my Artistic Scoring Ebook linked below!

If you try this loaf, tag @the.sourdough.mama on Instagram- I love seeing your creations and often share them!

My Go-To Sourdough Bread Recipe

My Go-To Sourdough Bread Recipe for Sourdough Art

Looking for the Artistic Scoring Steps? Be sure to read the step-by-step artistic process in the blog post above- this recipe card is just for making the dough you’ll create your art on. This is my foundational sourdough recipe- the one I use for nearly all my artistic loaves. It’s simple, reliable, and creates a dough that’s the perfect “bread canvas” for sourdough art. Watch the video HERE!
Prep Time:2 days
Keyword: artistic sourdough, bread art, go to recipe, go-to sourdough bread recipe, simple sourdough bread recipe, sourdough, sourdough art, sourdough bread
Servings: 1

Equipment

  • Kitchen Scale
  • Mixing Bowl
  • Banneton
  • Bowl Cover or Towel
  • Breadmat or Parchment
  • Dutch Oven
  • Bread Lame or Razor Blade

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Mix- In a large bowl, combine your active starter and warm water. Stir until milky. Add flour and mix by hand for 2–3 minutes until no dry spots remain.
  • Rest & Add Salt- Cover the bowl with a towel and rest for 30 minutes. Add 10g salt plus a splash (~1 tablespoon) of water. Mix until fully incorporated- about 2-3 minutes.
  • Stretch & Fold- Over the next 1.5–2 hours, perform 3–4 rounds of stretch and folds, resting between each. If the dough is not holding it's shape, do 4 sets.
  • Bulk Fermentation- After the final fold, cover and rest at room temperature until the dough has risen, looks airy, and jiggles when you shake the bowl. In my San Diego kitchen, this usually takes 6 to 7 hours in the summer and about 8 to 9 hours in the winter, from when I begin the recipe up until shaping. Ex) If I began my recipe at 9 am and it looks ready to shape at 5pm this would be an 8 hour total bulk fermentation time.
  • Shape the Dough- Lightly flour your counter and shape into a boule or batard (round or oval). Roll up the dough like a burrito, then tighten the surface by pulling it toward you several times.
  • Cold Proof- Place into a floured banneton, cover, and refrigerate 12–72 hours.
  • Preheat Oven- Place your Dutch oven inside and preheat to 500°F for at least 30 minutes (ideally an hour).
  • Score- Flip the dough onto parchment or a bread mat. If doing intricate scoring, freeze the dough for 30–45 minutes before cutting.
  • Bake- Lower oven temp to 430°F. Bake 20 minutes covered, then 20 minutes uncovered. If browning too quickly, tent with foil near the end.
  • Cool & Enjoy- Let cool at least 30 minutes before slicing.

Notes

Tips for Success
  • Watch your dough, not the clock — temperature and starter strength change everything.
  • Every oven and Dutch oven performs a little differently, so you may need to experiment with baking times and temperatures to find what works best.
  • For crisp scoring, dust the top lightly with Thai rice flour before cutting.
  • Always bake on parchment or a bread mat for easy transfer into the Dutch oven.
  • Shop Beginner Tools HERE
Download the Recipe
Want a printable, beautifully designed version of this recipe? It includes shaping visuals, notes on timing, and links to my favorite tools. Download My Free Go-To Sourdough Bread Recipe PDF
 
Ready for Bread Art?
Check out my Artistic Scoring Ebook to get started making sourdough butterflies, bows, and more!

Join the List

You'll Also Love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating